Back to Blogs
Discover
The Bury St Edmunds Witch Trial That Influenced the Salem Witch Trials
Special thanks to Ivan Bunn, author and local historian, for his invaluable assistance with this blog.
The tragic story of Amy Denny and Rose Cullender, two elderly widows from Lowestoft accused, tried and executed for witchcraft in Bury St Edmunds, is preserved in a historical booklet entitled A Tryal of Witches.
Originally published in the 1680s and reprinted in 1716, the booklet on display at Moyse's Hall Museum gives a detailed account of the 1662 trial of Amy Denny and Rose Cullender and is thought to be one of the most detailed surviving accounts of an English witch trial.
The Story of Amy Denny and Rose Cullender
The memorial stone honoring the lives of Amy Denny and Rose Cullender in Lowestoft
Rose Cullender, born Rose Hicks, married William Cullender on April 18, 1625. Together, they had nine children, but tragically, five died before the age of ten due to a plague outbreak. Following William’s death, Rose, unable to inherit property as a woman, saw her home placed in trust for her eldest son, Thomas, then just 14. In her 60s, while living in this home, she was accused of witchcraft.
Amy Denny, whose surname was incorrectly recorded as “Duny” in the printed trial account, is more elusive. Research by local historian Ivan Bunn established Denny as her correct surname. The only known official record of her is the 1651 baptism of her son, Samuel, listing her husband as John Denny. According to historian Ivan Bunn, there is some evidence suggesting Amy and John may have originated from Beccles, where parish records show John Denny married Emma Heckleton (with Amy possibly being short for Emmy). They had three children baptised there.
Notably, John Denny appears frequently in the Manor Court Books as a defendant. Ivan speculates that his frequent legal troubles may have contributed to Amy becoming a target of the witch trials after his death in 1657.
Accusations
Samuel Pacy's home in Lowestoft
By 1662, belief in witches was waning but still strong enough to fuel accusations. To bring someone to trial, a formal process was required: an accuser had to present evidence before a magistrate to obtain an arrest warrant.
Samuel Pacy, a wealthy fish merchant and one of Lowestoft’s most influential figures, sought and obtained warrants from magistrate Sir Edmund Bacon for Rose and Amy’s arrest. Samuel's young daughters, Deborah and Elizabeth, played key roles as witnesses. Ironically, just two years after Rose and Amy’s execution, Samuel himself was accused of holding illegal religious meetings and stood trial in Bury St Edmund, but the outcome is not known. His brother, Nicholas Pacy, had immigrated to Salem, Massachusetts, in 1638, where he was granted land—linking the Pacy family to the infamous Salem Witch Trials three decades later.
Samuel's accusations against Amy Denny began when she attempted to buy herrings from him. For reasons unknown, he refused to sell to her. After being turned away a second time, Amy returned once more but was again refused. As she left, she mumbled something under her breath. Around the same time, Samuel’s daughter Deborah, aged seven—who had been unwell but recovering—suddenly suffered violent fits and stomach pains. She cried out at Amy, leading Samuel to suspect her of witchcraft. Two weeks later another of his daughters, eleven years old Elizabeth, was similarly stricken.
Similar accusations followed from other townspeople. Edmund Durrant, for example, refused to sell herrings to Rose Cullender, only for his daughter Ann to fall ill with stomach pains. Witnesses repeatedly described symptoms "like the pricking of pins."
A Grand Jury ultimately decided that Amy and Rose should stand trial.
The Trial
Sir Matthew Hale
The trial was held at the Assize Court in the Shirehall at Bury St Edmunds from 10–13 March 1662, with Sir Matthew Hale presiding, Lord Chief Justice of the King’s Bench and Lord Chief Baron of the Exchequer – the 2nd most senior judge in England.
Rose and Amy were transported to Bury Gaol before being brought to the Shirehall. They were charged with bewitching eight children, ranging in age from a few months to 18 years old. One child had died, allegedly due to witchcraft. They were also accused of bewitching Robert Sherington’s four horses. In total, 14 charges were filed against them, to which they both pleaded not guilty.
There was no legal defence for the accused, nor were they permitted to testify on their own behalf.
After Judge Hale’s instructions, the jury found them guilty within half an hour on 13 counts, though they were acquitted of bewitching Sherington’s horses.
After the verdict, Rose and Amy were allowed to speak, but their words were not recorded. The booklet simply states that they said “nothing material to anything that was proved against them.”
They were hanged on Monday, March 17, 1662, likely at Thingoe Hill or on Shirehouse Heath outside the North Gate of Bury St Edmunds. To this day, their final resting place remains unknown.
Influence on the Salem Witch Trials
Salem Witch Trials memorial. Our thanks to Salem Witch Museum for the photo
The 1662 trial of Amy Denny and Rose Cullender in Bury St Edmunds has an important connection with the Salem Witch Trials in Massachusetts in 1692. The Bury St Edmunds trial was later cited as a precedent during the Salem trials, and A Tryal of Witches, the published account of the case, was known and consulted in the context of the Salem proceedings. Historian Ivan Bunn highlights the significance of this connection, suggesting that the Salem trials might not have taken place had it not been for the earlier Bury St Edmunds trial.
The case is significant because 'A Tryal of Witches' is thought to be one of the most detailed surviving accounts of an English witch trial. Presided over by Sir Matthew Hale—who later became Lord Chief Justice of England—the trial is a chilling example of how deeply ingrained superstitions and by modern reckoning, practices that would be regarded as deeply flawed by modern legal standards contributed to the convictions and executions.
Historian Ivan Bunn argues that, despite being a respected legal figure, Hale ignored evidence of fraud, accepted hearsay testimony from young children, and allowed “spectral evidence” from single witnesses.
In the years following the trial, clergyman John Hale recorded that those involved in the Salem proceedings had consulted precedents and writings on witchcraft, including Sir Matthew Hale’s A Tryal of Witches, the published account of the 1662 Bury St Edmunds trial.
A Tryal of Witches
A Tryal of Witches at The Assizes - an eyewitness account of the trial of Rose Cullender and Amy Denny, now on display at Moyse's Hall Museum
At Moyse's Hall Museum you can see a remarkable booklet - A Tryal of Witches.
Originally published in the 1680s and reprinted in 1716, the booklet gives a detailed account of the 1662 trial of Amy Denny (her surname is incorrectly recorded as Duny) and Rose Cullender, although the trial date is mistakenly given as 1664.
It is thought to be one of the most detailed surviving accounts of an English witch trial.
The booklet, its purchase funded by The Friends of Moyse's Hall Museum and The Bury Society, is on display at Moyse's Hall Museum as part of its nationally important collection of items related to the witch trials, witchcraft and superstition.
Memorial
In December 2024, Lowestoft Town Council unveiled a memorial stone in honour of Amy and Rose, ensuring their story would not be forgotten.
Historian Ivan Bunn, co-author of A Trial of Witches – A Seventeenth-century Witchcraft Prosecution (hailed as a seminal work), has been instrumental in preserving their memory. The memorial can be found near the so-called “Witches Stones” area in Belle Vue Park, Lowestoft.
Reflecting on the case, Ivan Bunn remarked:
“It is incredible to realise that Amy Denny and Rose Cullender were tried by the full ‘majesty’ of the English legal system, and that their case was heard by some of the most learned intellectuals in Law, Medicine, Science, and Philosophy of the time. It is a lesson for us all when studying this trial.”
In 2025 Moyse's Hall Museum in Bury St Edmunds formed a transatlantic partnership with The Salem Witch Museum in Massachusetts, USA, to explore the shared history of the infamous witch trials.
Related Blogs
Inside the Bury St Edmunds Witch Trials: A…
You can see a 300-year-old rare book, giving an…
View More
Town’s Museum Forms New Partnership with US…
Moyse’s Hall Museum will be forging links with a…
View More
The Largest Witch Trial in English History?
What is believed to be the largest witch trial in…
View MoreLatest news
News
A Time of Witches: Discover the real Bury St Edmunds locations that inspired Madeline Martin's Book
Step into the pages of A Time of Witches: Discover the real Bury St Edmunds locations.
News
Abbeygate Cinema Voted One Of The Top 5 Best Cinemas in the UK
Abbeygate Cinema has been voted one of the 5 best cinemas in the UK in the British Independent Film Awards’ (BIFA) Cinema of the Year awar.
News
Memorial to Honour the Victims of the Witchcraft Trials in Bury St Edmunds Unveiled
A first memorial to honour the victims of the witchcraft trials in Bury St Edmunds by Kate Jackson and John Williams has been installed at Moyse’s Hall Museum.
News
High Demand for Town Tours
Record Breaking Year for Bury St Edmunds Tour Guides Ghostly and Maacabre Walks!
News
Horror isn’t just for Halloween at Moyse’s Hall
Horror is not just for Halloween in West Suffolk where visitors will have plenty to sink their teeth into at a new exhibition that opens this weekend.
News
Bury St Edmunds reaches Dog Friendly Awards finals for fourth year running
The historic Suffolk town won the title of the UK’s Most Dog Friendly Town in 2024, and is now hoping to reclaim the title.
News
First Memorial for Victims of the Bury St Edmunds Witchcraft Trials
New memorial at museum will focus on the victims and a new play will bring to life the trial that links Bury St Edmunds to Salem.
News
St Edmundsbury Cathedral Launches 2027 Dogs In The Cathedral Calendar
Twelve local dogs were photographed for the 2027 calendar!
News
Where to See Santa in Bury St Edmunds
Our guide to where you can see Santa this Christmas in Bury St Edmunds!
Frequently asked questions
- What is the trial that links Bury St Edmunds in Suffolk, England with the Salem witch trials in Massachusetts, USA?
Before Salem, there was Bury St Edmunds. The trial of Amy Denny and Rose Cullender in Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk, England, in March 1662. The trial was presided over by Sir Matthew Hale, Lord Chief Justice of the King’s Bench and Lord Chief Baron of the Exchequer – the 2nd most senior judge in England. The case is significant because it remains one of the most detailed records of an English witch trial. The publication 'A Tryal of Witches' (a rare copy of which is now on display in Moyse’s Hall Museum in Bury St Edmunds) was consulted by Salem magistrates when determining what types of evidence were admissible, including 'spectral' evidence.
Historian Ivan Bunn notes that the Salem trials "might not have taken place had it not been for the trial of Amy Denny and Rose Cullender in Bury St Edmunds.